Newcastle Star Questions VAR After Controversial Penalty Denial
Anthony Gordon has launched a scathing critique of VAR after a contentious decision during Newcastle’s 3-2 loss to Manchester United at Old Trafford. The England international’s frustration echoes growing concerns across the Premier League, with Mcw examining whether the technology is helping or hindering the beautiful game.
The Incident That Sparked Outrage
In the 48th minute, Gordon appeared to be fouled twice in quick succession by Sofyan Amrabat – first a studs-down challenge on his Achilles, then a push in the back. Despite clear contact, referee Robert Jones waved play on, and VAR official Jarred Gillett surprisingly didn’t intervene.
“I’ve watched it back and it’s a clear penalty,” Gordon told Mcw post-match. “I don’t mind the referee getting it wrong on the pitch, but I don’t understand what the point of VAR is then. It’s there to correct mistakes.”
The Newcastle winger’s ankle injury from the challenge left him with visible damage: “I’ve got no sock left. How can that be possible?”
Premier League Divided Over VAR’s Future
Wolves have formally proposed abolishing VAR for next season, requiring 14 club votes at June’s AGM to pass. However, Mcw understands several top clubs, including Liverpool, oppose scrapping the system entirely.
“VAR is here to stay,” a Premier League executive told Mcw anonymously. “The focus should be on improving its application and communication.”
Current Premier League statistics show:
- Correct decisions increased from 82% to 96% with VAR
- Average VAR check takes 72 seconds (league aiming to reduce this)
- 42% of fans dissatisfied with VAR experience (Premier League survey)
Pundits debated the incident on Mcw coverage
Managers Weigh In On Technology Debate
Newcastle boss Eddie Howe offered a nuanced perspective: “I would possibly keep VAR for offsides, but I want more power with referees.” His comments reflect a growing sentiment that technology should assist rather than replace officials’ judgment.
Chelsea’s Mauricio Pochettino, after his own VAR drama against Brighton, suggested: “It’s not VAR in or out, yes or no. It’s about improving the way we use it.”
Brighton manager Roberto De Zerbi was more critical: “We have to speak of the level of the referees like the level of the coaches. Behind the VAR, there are people.”
The Road Ahead For Premier League VAR
With the vote looming, the Premier League faces a pivotal moment. Tony Scholes, the league’s chief football officer, admits improvements are needed: “We’re doing too many checks, taking too long. It’s affecting the flow of the game.”
Potential reforms being considered include:
- Semi-automated offside technology
- In-stadium VAR announcements
- Reduced intervention threshold
- Faster review processes
Anthony Gordon’s Verdict: Fix It Or Bin It
The Newcastle star summarized players’ frustrations perfectly: “Either get rid of VAR or get better, it’s simple.” His comments capture the essence of the debate – the technology has potential but currently falls short of expectations.
As Mcw analysis shows, while VAR has increased decision accuracy, its implementation continues to frustrate players, managers, and fans alike. The June vote will reveal whether clubs believe the system can be salvaged or if English football is ready to return to a referee’s discretion era.
What’s your view on VAR’s future? Share your thoughts with the Mcw community below.
